The Creation of the Basic Inventions Classification Model for the Estimating Significance of Intellectual Property Objects considering the Development of Means of Protection against Weapons of Mass Destruction

The relevance of the article is conditioned by the necessity to form scientific and methodological support for the process of identifying promising technical solutions, carried out in the course of scientific and technical examination of military and dual-purpose innovative projects on behalf of the Russian Federation Armed Forces. The aim of the paper is to create the basic inventions classification model for the estimating significance of intellectual property objects, namely weapons of mass destruction-oriented patents and utility models. The article is based on the system analysis and expert questioning methods. During research the authors suggested the basic inventions classification model, which includes preselection of inventions based on the predictive availability criterion, technical, scientific, techno-economic value estimation and calculation of integral value index. For the predictive prospectivity estimation, the universal selection forms of inventions were developed, which are matrix-type evaluation tables that take into account various characteristics of inventions, ranked by degree of importance; the universal selection forms for each type of invention («device», «method», «substance», «new purpose application») and groups of inventions («substance + method», «device + method») were developed as well. A new criterion characterizing the legal status of the invention for technical value estimation by the patent-legal indicators of the protection document is proposed. The obsolescence index of the techno-economic value calculation formula, which allows for more accurate calculations is introduced. The authors also grounded the time interval within which patent documents are searched for identifying the basic invention, equal to an average of ten years.

1. Skornjakov E.P. Theory and practice of patent study. Moscow: Information Publishing Center «Patent», 2014 (in Russian).

2. Skornjakov E.P., Gorbunova M.E. Classification of most effective patents of world patent fond for research and development application. Moscow: Information Publishing Center «Patent», 2008. (in Russian).

3. Altshuller G.S., Vertkin I.M. How to become a genius. Life strategy for creative personality. Minsk: Belorussia, 1994 (in Russian).

4. Poljakov V. Strategy of choice // Inventor and Innovator. 1982. № 8. P. 6 (in Russian).

5. Korchagin A.D. Value estimation of inventions in conditions of radical economic restructuring // Questions of Invention. 1988. № 4. P. 9 (in Russian).

6. Moskovchenko A.D. Methodological problems of technical invention // TUSUR Reports. 2007. № 1 (15). P. 239–243 (in Russian).

7. Avdzeyko V.I., Karnyshev V.I., Mescheryakov R.V. Patent analysis. identification of promising and breakthrough technologies // Russian Journal of Innovation Economics. 2018. V. 8(1). P. 79–80. (in Russian).

8. Udell G.G. Unvention evaluation services. A review of the state of the art // J. Prod. Innov. Manag. 1989. № 6. P. 157–168.

9. Abbas A., Zhang L., Khan S. A literature review on the state-of-the-art in patent analysis // World Patent Information. 2014. V. 37, P. 3-13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wpi.2013.12.006

10. Nikonova O.N., Kleshchenko E.D., Shvedova V.V. Integral value of technical solutions estimation // Intellectual Property. Industrial Property. 2018. № 9. P. 21–30 (in Russian).

11. Nikonova O.N., Frolov D.V., Sorokin A.I., Kleshchenko E.D. Estimating significance of inventions considering the type of a patenting object // Intellectual Property. Industrial Property. 2020. № 6. P. 43–51 (in Russian).

12. Gmoshinskii V.G. Engineering projection. Moscow: Energoizdat Publ., 1982. 282 p. (in Russian).

13. Kalinin A.G. Data processing by methods of mathematical statistics: monograph. Chita: ZIP SibUPK, 2015. 106 p. (in Russian).

14. Skornjakov E.P. Paten research. Moscow: Information Publishing Center «Patent», 2006. 163 p. (in Russian).

15. Mukhopad V.I. Economics and commercialization of intellectual property. Moscow: Magister, 2017. 512 p. (in Russian).

16. Technical level coefficient calculation program of weapons and defense technology «KTU» / Nikonova O.N., Kleshchenko E.D., Frolov D.V. Applicant and copyright holder Federal State Budgetary Establishment «33 Central Scientific Research Test Institute» of the Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation. № 2015613188; declared 21.04.2015; publ. 20.06.15 (in Russian).

17. Technical Level Coefficient Calculation of Industrial, Developing and Advanced Protection Means against WMD «TechLevel»: № 2018660283/Nikonova O.N., Frolov D.V., Tjazhin O.N. et al.; applicant and copyright holder Federal State Budgetary Establishment «33 Central Scientific Research Test Institute» of the Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation. № 2018618240; declared 26.07.18; publ. 21.08.2018 (in Russian).

18. Integral value index calculation of technical solutions «Integral»: № 2018660282 / Nikonova O.N., Kleshchenko E.D., Sorokin A.I. et al.; applicant and copyright holder Federal State Budgetary Establishment «33 Central Scientific Research Test Institute» of the Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation. № 2018618237; declared 26.07.18; publ. 21.08.2018 (in Russian).

19. Integral Value Index Estimation of Inventions on Variable Characteristics «IntSign»: № 2021614673 / Zlobina Y.P., Nikonova O.N., Frolov D.V. et al.; applicant and copyright holder Federal State Budgetary Establishment «33 Central Scientific Research Test Institute» of the Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation. № 2021613436; declared 16.03.21; publ. 29.03.2021 (in Russian).