Development and Human Testing of Chemical Warfare Agents and Means of Treatment of Lesions in Germany in 1933–1945

Despite serious attention to the issues of war crimes and crimes against humanity, committed on an unprecedented scale in concentration camps in Nazi Germany, the problem of medical experiments on prisoners appears to be one of the least-studied in modern Russian historiography. Moreover, no special attention was paid to testing chemical weapons on humans. The aim of this work is to review the history of the development and testing of chemical warfare agents (CWA) in Germany in 1933–1945. During the First World War, Germany was one of the leading countries in the sphere of military chemistry in the world. After the Versailles treaty this potential was largely lost as a result of the restrictions. After the National Socialist German Workers' Party (NSDAP) came to power, Germany not only restored, but also increased its military power and achieved a qualitative superiority over its opponents in the field of chemical weapons. The tests of CWA, as well as the study of the effectiveness of the means and protocols for the treatment of the lesions caused by CWA, were carried out both by the military structures of the Wehrmacht and the SS, and by civilian research and academic institutions. Experiments on prisoners were carried out in the concentration camps of Dachau, Ravensbrück, Auschwitz-Birkenau, Buchenwald, Sachsenhausen, Natzweiler-Struthof, Neuengamme, etc. Basically, the damaging effects of sulfur mustard and phosgene was investigated. In Auschwitz-Birkenau «a study of the action of various chemical preparations was carried out on the orders of German firms». After the war several SS doctors, who performed involuntary experiments on humans, were convicted by military tribunals for war crimes and crimes against humanity. Seven doctors were sentenced to death and executed on June 2, 1948, at the prison for war criminals in Landsberg, Bavaria. As a result of the Nuremberg trials, the Nuremberg Code was drawn up. It was the first international document that introduced ethical standards for scientists engaged in experiments on humans. It consisted of 10 principles, including the necessity of voluntary informed consent of the patient for the participation in medical experiments after providing him with full information about the nature, duration and purpose of the experiment; on the methods of its implementation; about all the perceived inconveniences and dangers associated with the experiment, and, finally, the possible consequences for the physical or mental health of the subject, which may arise as a result of his participation in the experiment.

1. Supotnitskiy M.V., Petrov S.V., Kovtun V.A. The Influence of Chemical Weapons on Tactics and Operational Art in World War 1 (Essays in the History of Chemical Weapons), Part 3 // Journal of NBC Protection Corps. 2017. V. 1; № 1. P. 53–68; № 2. P. 39–63; № 3. P. 51–78 (in Russian).

2. Supotnitskiy M.V., Petrov S.V., Kovtun V.A. Chemical Weapons in World War I. М.: Russian Panorama, 2020. 446 p. (in Russian).

3. Bretislav Friedrich. From Berlin-Dahlem to the Fronts of World War I: The Role of Fritz Haber and His Kaiser Wilhelm Institute in German Chemical Warfare // One Hundred Years of Chemical Warfare: Research, Deployment, Consequences (pp.25-44) https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-51664-6_3

4. Henning E., Kazemi M. Dahlem – Domain of Science. A walking tour of the Berlin institutes of the Kaiser Wilhelm / Max Planck Society in the «German Oxford». 4th ed., expanded and updated. Berlin. 2009. Р. 97.

5. Treaty of peace with Germany (treaty of Versailles). Transl. from French orig. Moscow, 1925. 197 p. (in Russian).

6. Troops of radiation, chemical and biological protection. 100 years. M., 2018.

7. Shilo N.I. First Attempts to Ban Chemical Weapons // Journal of NBC Protection Corps. 2018. V. 2. № 1. P. 48–69 (in Russian).

8. The Problem of Chemical and Biological Warfare. Vol. I. The Rise of CB Weapons. SIPRI, 1971.

9. Mills, A.K. Investigations of Chemical Warfare Installations in the Munsterlager area, including Raubkammer. CIOS File No. XXXI-86, ed. SHAEF Combined Intelligence Objectives Sub-Committee—G-2 Division, London. 1945.

10. Schmaltz F. Neurosciences and Research on Chemical Weapons of Mass Destruction in Nazi Germany // J. History Neurosci.: Basic and Clin. Perspectives. 2006. V. 15. № 3. P. 186–209. http://doi.org/10.1080/09647040600658229

11. Bunnett J.F., Mikolajczyk M. Arsenic and Old Mustard: Chemical Problems in the Destruction of Old Arsenical and «Mustard» Munitions. NATO ASI Series. Disarmament Technologies. V. 19. 1998.

12. Baader G., Lederer S.E., Low M., et al. Pathways to Human Experimentation, 1933–1945: Germany, Japan, and the United States. Osiris. 2005; 20:205-31. https://doi.org/10.1086/649419

13. Brown M. Military Chemical Warfare Agent Human Subjects Testing: Part 1 – History of Six-Decades of Military Experiments with Chemical Warfare Agents // Military Medicine. 2009. V. 174. № 10. P.1041.

14. National Academy of Sciences, Institute of Medicine: Committee to Survey the Health Effects of Mustard Gas and Lewisite: Veterans at Risk: Health Effects of Mustard Gas and Lewisite. Washington, DC, National Academy Press, 1993.

15. Nelga I.A., Medvetsky I.V., Zlobin A.V., Tretyakov S.V., Sherstyuk A.V., Kostyuchenko I.V. Chemical Weapons: History of the Study of Organophosphorus Toxic Agents Abroad // Journal of NBC Protection Corps. 2019. V. 3. № 2. P. 175–193 (in Russian).

16. Reitzenstein J. Himmlers Forscher. Wehrwissenschaft und Medizinverbrechen im «Ahnenerbe» des SS. Paderborn: Ferdinand Schöning Verlag, 2014.

17. Рецензия на: Reitzenstein J. Himmlers Forscher. Wehrwissenschaft und Medizinverbrechen im «Ahnenerbe» des SS. Paderborn; Ferdinand Schöning Verlag, 2014. см. URL: https://www.recensio.net/rezensionen/zeitschriften/recensio-moskau/2018-9/ReviewMonograph154519422, https://perspectivia.net/receive/pnet_mods_00000890? (дата обращения: 13.06.2021).

18. Toledano R. Anatomy in the Third Reich – The Anatomical Institute of the Reichsuniversität Strassburg and the deliveries of dead bodies // Ann. Anatomy – Anatomischer Anzeiger. 2016. V. 205. P. 128–144. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aanat.2016.03.006

19. Lang H.-J. August Hirt and «extraordinary opportunities for cadaver delivery» to anatomical institutes in National Socialism: A murderous change in paradigm // Ann. Anatomy – Anatomischer Anzeiger. 2013. V. 195. № 5. P. 373–380. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aanat.2013.03.013

20. Schmaltz F. Chemical weapons research in National Socialism: The collaboration of the Kaiser Wilhelm institutes with the military and industry // In: The Kaiser Wilhelm Society under National Socialism / Ed. Heim S., Sachse C., Walker M. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009. P. 312–338.

21. Ash M.G. Die Kaiser-Wilhelm Gesellschaft im Nationalsozialismus. Published online: 20 April 2010. http://doi.org/10.1007/s00048-009-0011-8

22. F. Lo´pez-Mun˜ oz. The pharmaceutical industry and the German National Socialist Regime: I.G. Farben and pharmacological Research. // J. Clin. Pharm. Therapeutics. 2009. V. 34. P. 67–77.

23. Stephen L. McFarland. Preparing for What Never Came: Chemical and Biological Warfare in World War II // Defense Analysis. V. 2. No. 2. 1986. Р. 108.

24. Preuss J. The Reconstruction of Production and Storage Sites for Chemical Warfare Agents and Weapons from Both World Wars in the Context of Assessing Former Munitions Sites / Eds. Friedrich B. et al. One Hundred Years of Chemical Warfare: Research, Deployment, Consequences. 2017. Р. 291.

25. Paka V.T. Dumped chemical weapons: the state of the problem // Ross. Chim. Zh. (J. of the Russian Chemical Society named after D.I.Mendeleev). 2004. T. XLVIII. № 2. P. 106 (in Russian).

26. Old Chemical Weapons Reference Guide. May 1998. Section 4-3.

27. U.S. Army Chemical Materiel Destruction Agency. Old Chemical Weapons: Munitions Specification Report. September 1994.

28. Entsorgung von kampfmittelbelasteten Böden am Beispiel der GEKA.

29. Weindling Р. The Origins of Informed Consent: The International Scientific Commission on Medical War Crimes, and the Nuremberg Code // Bull. History Med. 2001. V. 75. № 1. Р. 37–71.

30. Sass H.-M. Reichsrundschrefben 1931: PreNuremberg German Regulations Concerning New Therapy and Human Experimentation // J. Med. Philosophy. 1983. V. 99. P. 111.

31. Schmaltz F. Chemical Weapons Research on Soldiers and Concentration Camp Inmates in Nazi Germany // In: One Hundred Years of Chemical Warfare: Research, Deployment, Consequences / Eds. Friedrich B. et al. http://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-51664-6_13

32. Aristov S.V. Daily life of Nazi concentration camps. Moscow: Young Guard, 2017 (in Russian).

33. Schmaltz F. Otto Bickenbach's Human Experiments with Chemical Warfare Agents and the Concentration Camp Natzweiler // In: Man, Medicine, and the State: the Human Body as an Object of Government Sponsored Medical Research in the 20th Century / Ed. Eckart W.U. Stuttgart: Steiner, 2006. P. 139–156.

34. Schmaltz F. Kampfstoff-Forschung im Nationalsozialismus. Zur Kooperation von KaiserWilhelm-Instituten, Militär und Industrie. Göttingen: Wallstein Verlag, 2005.

35. Daan de Leeuw. In the Name of Humanity. Nazi Doctors and Human Experiments in German Concentration Camps, 1939–1945. University of Amsterdam, Department of History Master’s Thesis in History. 2013.

36. Glotova S.V. Crimes against humanity: genesis and modern understanding of the concept // Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law. № 3. 2016. P. 101–108 (in Russian).

37. Barsegov Yu.A. Declaration of 1915 – the stage of formation of international responsibility for genocide // Turkish doctrine of international law in the service of the policy of genocide (on the concept of a member of the «Reconciliation Commission» Gündüz Aktan) M., 2002. URL: http://www.armenianhouse.org/barsegov/genocide-ru/doctrine/doctrine.html#6 (in Russian).

38. Valeev R.M. Codification of Crimes Against Humanity (to the 70th Anniversary of the Nuremberg Trials) // Legal Science. 2015. № 3. P. 69–74 (in Russian).

39. The Nuremberg Trials: Collection of Materials. In 8 volumes.V. 5. M.: Jurid. Lit., 1991.672 p (in Russian).

40. SS in Action. Documents About SS Crimes. Translated from German. Moscow: SVETOTON, 2000. 624 p. (in Russian).

41. Enactments and Approved Papers of the Control Council and Coordinating Committee. Allied Control Authority. Germany. 1945. Volume I. Legal Division. Office of Military Government for Germany (US). P. 306–307.

42. Trials of war criminals before the Nuernberg military tribunals under Control Council Law No. 10. Volume I. Nuernberg. October 1946–April 1947. (The Medical Case) Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1949–1953.

43. Weindling P. From Clinic to Concentration Camp. Reassessing Nazi Medical and Racial Research, 1933–1945. 2017.

44. Benedek T.G. Case Neisser: Experimental Design, the Beginnings of Immunology, and Informed Consent // Perspectives in Biology and Medicine. V. 57. № 2. 2014. P. 249–267.

45. Vollmann J., Winau R. Informed consent in human experimentation before the Nuremberg code. // British Med. J. 1996. V. 313. Р. 1445–1447.

46. Vollmann J., Winau R. The Prussian Regulation of 1900: Early Ethical Standards for Human Experimentation in Germany // Ethics and Human Research. 1996.V. 18. № 4. Р. 9–11.

47. Siluyanova I.V. «Nuremberg Code» and its significance for modern science // Medical Ethics. 2014. V. 2. № 1. P. 85–88 (in Russian).

48. Chuchalin A.G. Voluntary informed consent // Pulmonology. 2021. V. 31. № 1. P. 116–120 (in Russian).

49. Petrova T.N. Unhuman medicine: prohibitions of Nuremberg // In: Results of the Nuremberg trial and modern challenges. Materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference / Ed. A.I. Bastrykin. 2016. P. 157–162 (in Russian).

50. Trubetskova E.G. Notes of a Doctor by V. Veresaev in the Context of Ethical Problems of Contemporary Medicine // Izv. Saratov Univ. (N.S.), Ser. Philology. Journalism. 2020. V. 20. № 2. P. 207–211 (in Russian).

51. Helsinki Declaration of the World Assembly of Physicians. Recommendations for Physicians Carrying Out Biomedical Research // Radiation and Risk (Bulletin of the National Radiation Epidemiological Register). 1997. №. 10. P. 16–18 (in Russian).